We interviewed a board-certified dermatologist, an ophthalmologist, and two optometrists for their recommendations and commentary on the best mascaras for sensitive eyes. The experts we spoke to include: Dr. Rose loves this mascara because it’s free of parabens, coal tar dyes, and several other offenders, and it actually performs. “I am still trying to wrap my head around how this one isn't a waterproof mascara because it stays put so well,” she explains.

NEUTROGENA® Eye Makeup Products | NEUTROGENA®

Just like any makeup, mascara does expire. The more important issue is the growth of bacteria in the bottle and the risk of infection, especially if you are using preservative-free mascara. Dr. DeRosa recommends throwing out your mascara every three months (or sooner). Instantly plumps the look of your lashes. This hyaluronic acid, vitamin E and keratin enriched mascara adds a boost of hydration and shine. Works to hydrate and replenish dry and brittle lashes. There are cosmetics designed for sensitive eyes. But the wrong or outdated mascara can cause an eye infection or allergic reaction. Corneal abrasions may also occur during application. This mascara from Èyes Are The Story was designed specifically with eye health in mind. Dr. Rose notes that this female-founded, eye-friendly mascara is a breath of fresh air for optometrists everywhere. “It was a pioneer product, launched intentionally with ocular safety in mind,” she explains. “Not only are the ingredients super clean, but each set comes with three mini tubes, which makes staying compliant with frequent cosmetic replacement (so you don't get unwanted bacteria buildup) a breeze.”Some folks have complained that this mascara is difficult to wash off. If that’s the case for you, consider using a cleansing oil to remove your eye makeup, and then following it up with a second cleanser afterward. Cholesterol/Lanosterol Ester, Limnanthes Alba (Meadowfoam) Seed Oil, Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil, Prunus If you suffer from sensitive eyes, you probably already know how much of a pain it can be to deal with mascara. From excessive smudging thanks to watery eyes to redness from an irritating formula, finding a mascara that won’t bother sensitive eyes can be a challenge. We appreciate that this mascara can be easily found at your local drugstore. Some folks have found this mascara to be a bit drying and flakes easily. It’s common for certain ingredients in mascara to irritate sensitive eyes. But fear not, beauties. There are specially formulated hypoallergenic mascaras available that can give you all the sass with none of the side effects. Best mascara for sensitive eyes

Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara, Black Brown, 0.21 Ounce

It comes in two shades and a wand that’s a bit thinner than other volumizing mascaras you might see on the market. This mascara works well for a really natural lash look, but if you’re on the hunt for a mascara that will really add a lot of “wow” to your sparse lashes, this probably won’t do it for you.

What is in mascara that irritates the eyes?

My eyelashes are not full and I wanted something to plump them up and waterproof and this mascara fit the bill.”